Follow ChabadInfo & Never Miss an Update!

Follow us on Instagram Subscribe to our WhatsApp status and broadcast Follow us on Tiktok Follow us on Facebook Follow us on X Follow us on Google News Subscribe on YouTube

In this focused 4-minute-40-second deep dive with Rabbi Heschel Greenberg, we unpack one of the most practical and controversial halachos in all of Hilchos Matnos Aniyim: Can someone take pei’ah (the poor man’s corner of the field) on behalf of a specific poor person? And what happens when a gizbar (community treasurer) tries to redirect tzedakah money that was mentally designated for poor people in another city?

The Rambam gives a clear but shocking answer in Hilchos Matnos Aniyim 4:19. Then the Tzemach Tzedek brings this exact question in Yoreh Deah and compares the gizbar to a shaliach (agent) versus a poel (worker). The Shach, Tumim, and Nesivos all weigh in — and the implications for modern Jewish fundraising, designated donations, GoFundMe campaigns, and community tzedakah funds are massive.

📚 In this Rambam In-Depth episode we explore:
• The exact Rambam in Hilchos Matnos Aniyim 4:19 and why only a poor person can acquire pei’ah for someone else
• The chav l’acherim problem — why taking for one person can harm the poor people standing right there
• Why a wealthy person is barred from acquiring on behalf of others (even with good intentions)
• The Tzemach Tzedek’s famous question about a gizbar who wanted to redirect funds from another city’s poor to his own town
• The explosive debate: Is a gizbar just a regular shaliach, a stronger poel, or something even more powerful?
• Why the Tumim and Nesivos disagree with the Shach — and why the Tzemach Tzedek says a gizbar is stronger than all of them
• The lingering question that still affects every Jewish community fund today

🕰️ Timestamps:

00:00 – Welcome & Why This Tiny Rambam Changes Everything
00:28 – The Rambam’s Rule on Taking Pei’ah for a Specific Poor Person
01:05 – Why Only a Poor Person Can Acquire It for Someone Else
01:45 – The Tzemach Tzedek’s Gizbar Question (The Real Drama Begins)
02:20 – Shaliach vs Poel vs Gizbar: The Halachic Power Ranking
03:05 – Why the Gizbar Might Be Stronger Than Everyone Thought
03:40 – The Unresolved Question That Still Affects Your Tzedakah Today
04:20 – Modern Applications & Your Action Step

💡 Key Insights You’ll Walk Away With:

• The critical difference between shlichus and yad poel and why it matters for every community treasurer
• How donor intent and communal authority collide in Jewish law
• Why “I meant it for someone else” doesn’t always work in halacha
• Practical takeaways for anyone who runs, gives to, or manages Jewish tzedakah funds in 2026

📚 Primary Sources

• Rambam, Hilchos Matnos Aniyim 4:19
• Teshuvos Tzemach Tzedek, Yoreh Deah (the gizbar redirection question)
• Shach, Tumim & Nesivos on Choshen Mishpat (the yad poel debate)

🤔 Reflection Questions for the Comments

• Have you ever designated money for a specific person or cause and later wanted to change it?
• Should a gizbar have more power than a regular shaliach? Why or why not?
• How should modern Jewish organizations handle donor-designated funds when needs change?

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I give tzedakah to a specific poor person through a gabbai and later change my mind?
A: It depends on whether the gabbai/gizbar had the halachic power to acquire it on that person’s behalf in the first place.

Q: Does this apply to online crowdfunding like GoFundMe?
A: The same principles of shlichus, donor intent, and chav l’acherim are being discussed by contemporary poskim regarding designated online donations.

Q: Why does the Rambam care so much about “harming the other poor people who are there”?
A: Because pei’ah is a zekhus (right) that belongs to whoever is present. Taking it for someone far away can deprive the local poor of their opportunity.

6