Why Miracles Alone Aren’t Enough: Lessons from Parshas Va’era
Parshas Va’era recounts the first seven plagues, showing G-d’s power yet failing to change Pharaoh’s heart. A story about The Rebbe highlights the lesson: miracles are temporary and don’t easily transform daily life. The future redemption will bring lasting miracles that deeply impact the world and our inner selves. Preparing for this requires learning Chassidic teachings and recognizing the presence of Moshiach • By Rabbi Tuvia Bolton • Full Article
This week we read of the first seven miraculous plagues that G-d brought on the Egyptians preceding the Exodus of the Jews. These events prepare us for the future Redemption as the prophet says:
“Like the days you left Egypt I will show you miracles.” (Micah 7:15)
In other words, just as these miracles enabled Moses to lead the Jews to redemption so Moshiach will lead the entire world with even bigger ones.
But this does not make sense. After all, the miracles had no effect.
After the last of these seven catastrophes the Torah tells us “And Pharaoh saw that the rain, hail and thunder stopped and he continued to sin and hardened his heart etc.” (Gen. 9:45)
So why did G-d make all these wonders for nothing? And what is it supposed to teach us about the redemption?
Not only that, why did He make so MANY miracles? If He wanted to free the Jews then why didn’t He just fly them out or make all the Egyptians unconscious or just stop creating them?
To answer this here is a story:
The story begins over fifty years ago in Jerusalem, a few days after Rosh HaShanna, Rabbi Chiam Tzvi Schwartz was packing his bags for his trip
He had been looking forward to it all year. Together with thousands of Chassidim, he would be with the Lubavitcher Rebbe from the Day of Forgiveness (Yom Kippur) through the Holiday of Joy (Succot).
He was just closing the suitcase when the phone rang and his wife yelled, “It’s a long distance call for you ” He picked it up,
“Hello,” the voice on the other end of the line said, “This is Rabbi Zalman Gurarie one of the Rebbe’s secretaries, how are you? You wrote a letter to the Rebbe asking for a blessing for your daughter, right? Well, the Rebbe answers that you should check your Tefillin.”
Rabbi Schwartz thanked him and slowly hung up the phone.
What should he do? True, he wrote the letter and still needed the blessing. But he wrote that letter two weeks ago. Since then, he bought a brand-new pair of very special and very expensive Tefillin that were sworn to be the ultimate in perfection. No reason to check them.
But on the other hand, the Lubavitcher Rebbe was never wrong.
In any case there was nothing he could do now; his plane was leaving in a few hours and there was no time to have them checked before he left.
He decided not use them till he had them checked which he would do immediately upon arriving in New York, and borrow Tefillin for the trip from someone he knew that had an extra pair.
Early that next morning, shortly after he arrived in America, he borrowed Tefillin from a family member, prayed the morning prayer and took his Tefillin to a scribe in Williamsburg where he was staying together and requested that they be checked urgently while he waited.
Sure enough, just a half-hour later the scribe announced that there was something wrong and showed him the parchment where an entire word was missing! The Tefillin were totally disqualified.
Rabbi Schwartz was shocked. Rarely is such a massive flaw to be found in even the worst Tefillin – and his were supposed to be of the highest quality!
But he didn’t have much time to think about it. He took a taxi to Brooklyn. In eight hours Yom Kippur would begin, and some ten thousand other Jews were standing in an immensely long line before 770 Eastern Parkway (the Chabad Headquarters) waiting to receive a piece of honey cake and a blessing from the Lubavitcher Rebbe before this holiest day of the year.
Finally his turn came. The Rebbe handed him his piece of cake and said, “Have a good sweet year” and continued, “And since you have to return to Israel anyway, it would be best to return as soon as possible after Yom Kippur in order to fix your Tefillin.”
Rabbi Schwartz was dumbfounded. How could the Rebbe possibly have remembered him from the tens of thousands of letters he receives, and how did he know that his Tefillin were disqualified!?
But upon hearing the Rebbe’s words he decided to change his ticket. He would return home immediately after Yom Kippur and not stay for Succot as he had planned. It was a big disappointment but the Rebbe was never wrong.
Three days later, a day after Yom Kippur, he was back in Israel.
As was his custom, whenever he returned to Israel, he would immerse himself in a mikva. As he entered the Mikva in the Maya Shaarim District of Jerusalem who ‘happened’ to be coming out but the very scribe that wrote and sold him the Tefillin!
The scribe was shocked to hear that the Tefillin were not kosher and even more so to hear that they were missing an entire word!!
“Why, those parchments had been checked five times by experts.” He repeated several times.
“Tell me” The Scribe asked, “Did the Lubavitcher Rebbe have something to do with this?”
“Yes,” answered Rabbi Schwartz “Of course. It was the Rebbe that told me to check them in the first place and then told me to hurry home to correct them. Actually, it’s quite a miracle that I am meeting you here now.”
“Oyyyy!! ” The scribe held his head and screamed.” What does he want from me!! This is the fifteenth time he has done this to me!! I take weeks, months writing them, have them checked over and over again and he makes them Posol (unfit). Why doesn’t he leave me alone!! What does he want from me!!!
Rabbi Schwartz listened to this outburst with interest and finally asked, “Tell me have you ever had any sort of trouble with the Rebbe? After all he is a very holy Tzaddik. Maybe you did something to anger him?”
“Who cares how holy he is!” said the scribe. “I have nothing with the Rebbe. Never said a word against him. I mean, I’m not one of his Chassidim and all those miracle stories don’t impress me but I just keep quiet about it.”
But after a few minutes he remembered.
“Well actually once there was something. It wasn’t against your Rebbe but against his father-in-law, the previous Rebbe. A long time ago, over ten years or more, I wrote an article in HaChoma (the Neturai Karta ultra-orthodox Jerusalem) magazine against the previous Lubavitcher Rebbe. You know, how he claimed to be the head of all the Jews.
Anyway, the present Rebbe, your Rebbe, wrote a letter to the Chief ultra-orthodox Rabbinic Court of Jeruselam, the Aida Charidit, about me saying that since I wrote such an article it was a certainty that my Tefillin would be unfit for use (Posol).
“Why he wrote to them I don’t know, but they contacted me and told me to have my Tefillin checked. So I did but it was a false alarm. My Tefillin were declared to be one hundred percent Kosher. So the Rebbe was wrong. But I didn’t make a storm about it.
“But that was years ago. And what does it have to do with me? And anyway, if anyone is wrong it’s the Rebbe not me. My Tefillin were Kosher! So why doesn’t he leave me alone!!!
“Tell me” Rabbi Schwartz asked “Where did you get those Tefillin? You know, the ones you had checked back then. Did you write them?”
“No” The scribe answered. “I didn’t write them. I inherited them from my father, but they were Kosher! The Rebbe was wrong.”
“No!!” yelled Rabbi Schwartz “Exactly the opposite! How holy and wondrous are the words and prophesies of the Lubavitcher Rebbe!
“When the Rebbe said that ‘your’ Tefillin would be posol: he meant the Tefillin that YOU WRITE would all be posol. And he was right! Every pair you write has been posol. The ones you had checked were not yours! That is why they were Kosher; they were your father’s.
The Scribe broke out in tears of remorse.
This answers out questions. Our section with all its plagues comes to tell us that just as the scribe in our story was not impressed by the miracle stories he heard about the Rebbe so too most people are not affected in a permanent or deep way by miracles (as we see from the Jews who worshipped the Golden Calf despite the miracles they experienced) And this is for two reasons:
Miracles are temporary and after they stop, they are just memories. And secondly miracles are abnormal and don’t easily translate into day-to-day life.
For both reasons their message, that G-d controls the world, isn’t lasting.
But the future redemption it will be different:
Then the miracles will be constant: the world will be filled with the knowledge of G-d, and also will affect the inner soul of each person. (As occurred to the scribe at the end of the story): there will be no hatred, jealousy or competition, everyone will know G-d.
And the preparation for all this is to learn the Chassidic teachings of the Baal Shem Tov, especially as they appear in the writings of Chabad: Lekutei Torah, Tanya, Torah Ohr and the discourses of the final Rebbe.
Then the Oneness of G-d [and the connection to the Moses (and Moshiach) of our generation] permeate our mind, heart and soul.
So we will have the desire and ablity to, as the Lubavitcher Rebbe said: “Open our eyes and see that…. Behold! Moshiach is here!!
It all depends on us.
We are standing on the merits of thousands of years of Jewish hopes, prayers and suffering. Now it could be that just one more good deed, word or even thought will bring ……
Moshiach NOW!!
Rabbi Tuvia Bolton
Yeshiva Ohr Tmimim
Kfar Chabad, Israel
47
Join ChabadInfo's News Roundup and alerts for the HOTTEST Chabad news and updates!