• Forgiving a Loan: Does Intention Count?

    What happens in a case where a creditor intended to pardon the debt, but before he had a chance to inform the debtor, the money was paid back? May he keep it or must he return it? By Horav Yosef Yeshaya Braun, member of the Badatz of Crown Heights  Full Article

    By Horav Yosef Yeshaya Braun, member of the Badatz of Crown Heights

    A principle of halachic transactions is g’miras daas (firm resolve), which is achieved through a kinyan (act of acquisition), a formalized, proprietary act transferring ownership—for example, a physical object exchanges hands between two parties—to “seal the deal.” However, when a creditor wishes to be mochel (forgive) a debt, his decision to do so suffices. There is no need for a kinyan, and he may be mochel shelo b’fanav (not before him), i.e., the loan can be forgiven even without the debtor being present.

    There is a discussion among poskim whether a lender can be mochel b’lev (in their heart, i.e. non-verbally) or whether the intention to forgive must be declared verbally. What happens, then, in a case where a creditor intended to pardon the debt, but before he had a chance to inform the debtor, the money was paid back? May he keep it or must he return it?

    Halachah speaks of a dispute over an object where one party is a muchzak (the presumed owner based on possession). In these particular circumstances, there is a minority opinion which states that the object belongs to the muchzak. Though we usually follow the majority, in this case the strength of de facto possession allows him to proclaim, “Kim li!” (I am of that [minority] opinion)—and the object is his. The same applies for a lender who was only mochel b’lev before the debtor paid up; since there are poskim who deem non-verbal dissolution as not binding, the lender may utilize the principle of kim li and keep the repaid loan.

    A creditor who is mochel cannot retract the pardon. Even if the retraction occurs toch k’dei dibbur (within the short span of a salutation, specifically, “Shalom alecha Rebbi!”—Greetings to you, Rabbi), according to some opinions, the pardon is binding—unless, of course, it was a mechilah b’taus (a pardon made in error).

    Similarly, a person who volunteers services or goods at no charge for the sake of doing a mitzvah, cannot backtrack and ask for payment.


    Tags: ,

    Related Posts:

    1. I don’t unerstand. Why is it only a “minority opinion” that in a dispute the property belongs to the muchzok? Isn’t the din always that hamotzie meichaveiro olov horaya?

    *Only proper comments will be allowed
  • Event Calendar

  • Tuesday, Oct 27th, Wedding – Shlome Wolvovsky – CH & Rochel Leah Matusof – Madison, WI @ Oholei Torah
  • Thursday Oct 29th Wedding: Devorah Bennish – Detroit & Mordechai Rubin – London @ Royalty House, MI
  • Sunday, Oct 25th, Sholli Miller – Chicago, IL & Batya Korf – Miami Beach, FL @ Bais Rivka 310 Crown Street
  • Thursday, Oct 22 Wedding: Chaim Boruch Bar-Chaim – CH & Shoshana Pimentelli – CH/TX @ Oholei Torah
  • Thursday, Oct 22 L’Chaim: Sruli Finck – CH & Chaya Mangel – Dayton, OH @ Chovevei Torah 885 Eastern Parkway
  • Tuesday, Oct 20th Wedding: Dovid Kaminetzky – Melbourne, AU & Chaya Okunov – Crown Heights @ Oholei Torah
  • Monday Oct 19 L’Chaim: Ari (Aaron) Levertov – Crown Heights & Debby Rabinowicz – Sao Paulo, Brazil @ Choivevey Torah
  • Monday, Oct 19 2015 Wedding: Mendy Zippel – Salt Lake City, UT & Fraidy Shagalov – Crown Heights @ Oholei Torah
  • Sunday 18th Oct. L’Chaim: Chananya Niassoff – CH & Tzirl Brennan – CH @ Bais Rivkah Crown St
  • Sunday Oct 18th – Wedding: Mendy Edelman – Crown Heights & Sara Lozenik – Miami, FL @ Oholei Torah
  • Tehilim

  • Urgent Tehillim Needed
  • Dov Chaim Ben Rivkah
  • Tzvi Hirsch Ben Guttel
  • Charna Alexandra bas Chana Esther
  • Ettie Bas Alte Miriam
  • Zissel Yehudis Bas Masha
  • Chaim Yosef Yitzchok Ben Sarah Elka
  • Devorah Bas Sarah
  • Boruch Ben Sarah
  • DovBer Ben Dina
  • Lost and Found

  • Lost Men’s Heavy Black Winter Jacket Size Large in 770
  • Lost in 770 before Pesach, a black Bradley Jons long coat size 38R. No lining and no belt. Almost brand new! Please call zalman at 347-788-0749
  • Found black hats outside 770, behind the Hatzalah ambulance
  • lost – Chitas bearing a blessing to Shmuel from Sarge. (Sargent Zvi Fisher z..l.v) [email protected] or +1-7869427070
  • LOST: in 770 a black Lenovo Intel core i5 laptop in a dark grey laptop bad together with a WD hard drive, if found please call Zalmy 347-788-0749
  • Found: Maroon Chitas
  • Found: Bag of Clothes
  • Found: Leather-Bound Pink Siddur
  • Lost: Box with Mini Shas from YSP
  • Lost: Rose Gold Bangle/Bracelet
  • Classifieds

  • Cook position for a local Mosad
  • Looking for a cook/kitchen manager
  • Administrator for a local Mosad Experience a must, and preferbiligual a bonus [email protected]
  • Looking for a cook/kitchen manager Experience a must. [email protected]
  • ‘Beis Mosiach’s’ to give away for free
  • Private Rooms for Men
  • Newly renovated Basement for rent
  • Judaica Store in Crown Heights is Looking to Hire
  • Looking for Work? Opportunity available, for a quick & efficient typist in Williamsburg. For more info: 201-800-1774
  • Lost in 770 Last Week: Transparant Bag of Tefillin, Rashi, R”T, Chitas – in black/grey 770 pouches